Monday, August 23, 2010

LEUNG Wing Yin (Charlie) talks on Durer's "Adam and Eve"




1) INTRODUCE THE DRAWING IN GENERAL TERMS

•What is the title of the drawing?
•What is the name of the artist?
•What is the year the drawing was done?
•What is the medium? (ie the materials used to produce the picture, for example charcoal on paper, pen and ink etc)
•What is the subject matter or general theme of the work? (eg is it a figure drawing, a map, a portrait, an autobiographical work, a picture about nature, a drawing of the city etc?)
The title of this drawing is " Adam and Eve", and it is drawn by Albrecht Dürer  (German, 1471–1528)and finished in 1504. It is a copperplate engraving.It is a figure drawing . (A myth of Adam and Eve) .


•What is the purpose of the drawing? (eg Is it a diagram that explains how something works? Does it record accurately record the appearance of something? Does it express the artist's emotion or memory? )
This drawing  shows Adam and Eve at the moment in which Eve accepts the fruit from the serpent. Dürer was depicting ideal human body proportions and render naturalness in his artworks.

 Panofsky said: " Durer wished to present to a Northern public two classic specimens of the nude human body, as perfect as possible both in proportion and in pose."
( "Albrecht Durer's Renaissance" by David Hotchkiss Price, the University of Michigan Press Ann Arbor,2006)

The main purpose of this drawing was embodied Durer's new ideas of beauty and harmony.

2) DESCRIBE THE DRAWING IN DETAIL

•How is line used? What does it do/express?
This drawing used lots of lines, and the lines are quite dense and tight here. We can clearly see the details in every objects, such as the muscles of the two main charactors, the texture of the tree, the expression of the animals, etc. Those detailed lines make the whole drawing very realistic.

The drawing mainly use smooth and soft lines, but also includes some heavy lines in the background. The heavy lines make the background  very dark, and it seems that the forest is so immense. The soft line in the front create a kind of sadness atmosphere.

The drawing includes some intend lines, Adam's eyeline lead people focus on Eva, and Eva's eyeline lead people to the apple. It makes you focus on the objects step by step.

•How is tone used? What does it do/express?
Durer used three different tone to draw this picture.

Firstly, Durer used the light tone: in the front of this picture, the tone is very light, it made you focus on the two main charactors Adam and eve.

Secondly, he used middle tone: you can see that the objects ( the front trees and the animals) behind adam and eve are a little bit darker than.

Thirdly,  he used very dark tone in the forest, so that it can serve as a background.

The tone makes different layers and let people focus on different part of the drawing.

•What can you say about shape and/or form in this picture? What is the effect?
The drawing have a sense of 3-Dimensional form. As Durer wanted to depict ideal human body proportions in this drawing, he used the lines carefully. Every things in this drawing seems very realistic.


The realistic objects make people think of the story behind this drawing.
•Is texture a feature of the drawing?

The lines and the shading show some of the texture  in the drawing: for example, the wooden texture of the tree, the muscles of the charactors.

•What can you say about the composition of the drawing? What is the effect of this type of composition on the overall drawing?
Adam and Eve was drawn in the centre, so that people may focus on them and then follow their eyeline to find other objects.

•Is rhythm important in this picture? If so, say more about it...
Yes, the rhythm is important and it comes from the Adam and Eve's eyeline. As Durer wanted people to look at every things step by step, it made the drawing more active and energetic.


•Is the picture balanced? Explain...
It is considerably balance in the picture. We can see a stam in the middle and it just like cutting the picture into two parts: one part is Adam and the other part is Eve.

•Is perspective used in the picture? If so, describe the way that the illusion of three-dimensional space has been created.
The forest here are very dark in the drawing, and Adam and Eve are much more light, so that we can clearly see that Durer used perspective to depict the drawing.

•Is the picture harmonious? If so, in what way? 
The picture is harmonious, the charactors do not have exaggerated facial expression and movement. Every objects here are quite dull and it just like a motionless scene. So that it create a harmonious and comfortable feeling.

•Are there any strong contrasts in the picture? Say more... 
It has a strong contrast in the picture.It is because the background here is very dark and the subject matter ( Adam and eve) are corresponsively light.


      3) INTERPRETATION AND EVALUATION

•What is the mood of the drawing? Justify your answer using information from your responses above

The mood of this drawing is peaceful and harmonious. We can see that Durer use different lines and tone, it made a sence of harmony  in the picture. This drawing  shows the moment before eating the forbidden fruit , man and woman were harmony with each other, and all nature peaceful and without threat. But actually, the garden of paradise is already mutating into a dark forest, primitive and uncivilied, already  warns of the threatening forces of nature.

 •What does the drawing express? Justify your answer using information from your responses above
The drawing want to show the experimenting with Durer's ideal of physical perfection. So that he draw the harmonious moment before eating the forbidden fruit.

"Adam and eve are presented at a moment of tension ,of pause,when all is still governed by divine harmony." ("Durer",by Norbert Wolf, TASCHEN,2007)

•In your opinion, why is this work interesting/moving/ clever/ imaginative/thought-provoking/......?  Choose the adjective(s) that best fit(s) the work, and then justify your conclusion in terms of specific features and qualities of the drawing.
This work is interesting to me, it is because the drawing is so plentiful and rich. It has lots of objects here, and every lines and tone are meticulous and detailed.
The use of the intend lines and  the  implication of the objects make the drawing living and vivid.




WAN Lai Na (Nina) talks on de Ryckere's Head of A Dying Man

Bernard de Ryckere, Head of A Dying Man, 1563


1) INTRODUCE THE DRAWING IN GENERAL TERMS

The drawing is called 'Head of a dying man' and it is drawn by Bernard de Ryckere in 1563. The medium of the drawing is chalks on paper. It is obviously a figure drawing and it depicts half of a dying man lying on a bed and shows a low-spirited and tired facial expression. The purpose of the drawing may be divided into two parts. First, it records accurately the appearance of a dying man, such as the angular face, half opened eyes and mouth. Also, it express the artist's emotion or memory. I just guess that the artist really saw the scene in real life and the scene impressed him very deeply, so he drew it on the paper in order to express his personal feeling.

2) DESCRIBE THE DRAWING IN DETAIL

About the line quality in the drawing, there are both thick and thin, smooth and rough, but it is mainly focus on the latter. And the types of line mainly emphaize on flowing, feathery and soft, but also includes some heavy lines. Since the theme of the drawing is about a dying man, so the painter uses such thin lines to depict a pale human face and show a sense of weak and lifeless. On the other hand, the painter uses rough lines to depict the shadow which makes a great contrast to the man. It seems that the background is much more stronger than the dying man.

In terms of the tone, the drawing is mainly depicted in black and white, and a little bit yellow colour, so black and white as the major tone of the image. It creates a gloomy and lifeless mood which mach up with the theme. There is a strong contrast between light and dark, such as the deep shadow behind comparing to the light head. Also, we can see other small contrast full of the drawing, such as the parts of neck and face. The artist describes the contrast between light and shade in detail so as to make the object more three-dimensional and show a sense of reality.

About the shape and form of this picture, it is clear to show a half of a dying man lying on a bed. We can see every detailed clearly, such as the angular face, low-spirited eye contact, half-open mouth and so on. As I mentioned before, the artist uses detailed lines and light and dark tone to generate a three-dimentional effect and make the object more real since the dying man just like in front of the audience and looking at us hardily. Such realistic form is effective to arouse people's emotional effect.

The drawing is a rough texture because of its sketchy quality and the prominent heavy lines, so it creates a harsh textured rather than a smooth surface. Especially, the artist uses rough brushstrokes to draw the shadows, using tight and dense brushstrokes to draw the detail of the object. As audience, we can see clearly the contour and construction of the human body, such as the pulse and bone.

About the composition of the drawing, the painter enlarges the head of the man and depicts it in the centre of the drawing. It shows a shallow and given space. This type of composition is effective to draw audience's attention since we are force to focus on the main and only one object in the drawing. Moreover, it is easy to express the emotion and impress the audience. Because the head of a dying man is shown clearly in the centre, so we may have a deep feeling through his facial expression.

As regards the rhythm in this picture, it is not a strong rhythm, but a weak and even no rhythm could be seen. As I mentioned before, the painter uses soft lines to depict the figure, so as to create a sense of inanimate and lifeless. It is impossible to see a strong rhythm through the lines since a dying man is not active and dynamic.

In terms of the perspective, it certainly helps to create the illusion of three-dimensional space. The space in this picture is narrow and small because the artist uses close-up to show the head of a dying man which lead us focusing on the facial detail. Moreover, according to the man's eyesight, he seems to look at the upper areas and the viewers just like standing to look at him from a high angle. Therefore, it creates a down to up perspective.

All elements of the pictures work together in harmony. Although there are contrast between both lines and tones, they are linking together in a very coherent and comfortable way. For example, the coordinating of light and dark generally creates a dull felling which gives us the sense of unitary and harmonious.

3) INTERPRETATION AND EVALUATION

Form the content of the drawing, I feel sad and sorrow because it is a scene depicted of a dying man. I can feel the pain and hopeless through his appearance, such as low-spirited eyes, half opened mouth, angular face and body. As I mentioned above, the use of light and dark contrast makes the object more three-dimensional and real, so the man just like in front of me and look at me hardily. Also, the tone of the drawing is dull which generates a feeling of unhappy. But on the other hand, when I emphasize on other aspects of the drawing, it seems peaceful rather than painful. For example, the lines of the man are very smooth and soft and the whole drawing is harmonious in different aspects which can reduce the painful feeling to some extent. Perhaps I take my own passion into analyzing this picture since I think subjectively that when it comes to death, it must be sorrow or painful, but it can also be natural die rather than suffering from illness. Although the picture provides me with both negative and possitive feeling, I think the unhappy emotion is more stronger than the other one.

Now I would like to talk about what does the drawing express. The drawng seems a record of a real situation because the painter uses tight brushstrokes to make the drawing more accurate and detailed, even the pulse can be seen in the drawing. Also the scene just like real because of the use of light and dark contrast. Furthermore, the painter express his sympathy and pity towards the object in the drawing. The evidence is that the dying man is not such sinister in appearance, but quite peaceful. Also, painter's compassion are fully reflected on the harmony of the whole picture.

In my opinion, the picture is moving and thought-provoking since it moves audience's emotion and provokes thought on the issue of death in terms of its general tone and feeling. The painter enlarges the head of a dying man in the centre of the drawing in order to catch our attention and generate certain kind of emotion which are pity and mercy. Also, the picture reminds me of the issue of death. What is the feeling when we are dying? What is the circumstance after death? What does death mean? And many question aroused in my mind.


Reference:

Tania Kovats, Drawing book: a survey of drawing: the primary means of expression, London: Black Dog Publishing, 2007

Yu Fanny talks on Women at the foot of cross

                                                         Women at the foot of cross
                                                               1538



•What is the title of the drawing?

The title of the drawing is women at the foot of cross.
•What is the name of the artist?

The name of the artist is Daniele Ricciarelli (c. 1509 – April 4, 1566), also known as Daniele da Volterra
He  was an Italian mannerist painter and sculptor.
•What is the year the drawing was done?

The drawing was done on 1538.


•What is the medium? (ie the materials used to produce the picture, for example charcoal on paper, pen and ink etc)

The medium of the picture is oil painting
•What is the subject matter or general theme of the work? (eg is it a figure drawing, a map, a portrait, an autobiographical work, a picture about nature, a drawing of the city etc?)

The subject of the picture  is a fainting women. It is a figure drawing. The fainting women is one of the character  form The Descent from the Cross , which  is about taking Christ from the cross. The theme of the picture is about Christian and the sad feeling.

.


•What is the purpose of the drawing? (eg Is it a diagram that explains how something works? Does it record accurately record the appearance of something? Does it express the artist's emotion or memory? )

 
  The fainting women is the Virgin Mary , who saw the burial and was crying
The drawing is to describle the  sadness of the crucifixion.


2) DESCRIBE THE DRAWING IN DETAIL
•How is line used? What does it do/express?

The line is soft and continous in order to express the weak and crying Mary. Moreover, the line used on the upper part of the figure is clear and bright since the light is directly towards her back and hair. On the contrast, the line used on  the lower part of the figure such as the hand, face, leg  is vough and dark. It expresses the shadow created by the leaning forward position. 

•How is tone used? What does it do/express?

The tone is formed by  the shading and monochromatic drawing. The dominant colour is brown;however, there are sevral layers of shading.There is little shading on the head of figure.The lower part of the figure is heavily shaded.

The sad contrasts of  light and dark, falling and supporting between the upper part and lower part of the figure help to make the paintings realism.

 It can form the realistic image of weaknesses and sadness.
•What can you say about shape and/or form in this picture? What is the effect?

There is only one figure in the picture. The shading creates the three-dimensional object. The leaning forward position is constructed by the shading.


The shape of the figure is to lean forward and cover her face by her hands.It can create the feeling of sadness.  The figure's  movement is exaggerated since it is the style of the painter.


The exaggerated form of the drawing is due to the painter's style. The painter's style is a mixture of  realism and exaggeration.


•Is texture a feature of the drawing?

The different layer of shading can reflect the strong movement of the figure. Also, there is smoky effect around the figure.It can reflect the cloth to be soft and light. Also, the wind may blow the cloth due to the smoky effect. 

However, the shading on the lower part of dress is strong and dark. The dress can be reflected as heavy and the leg is supporting the whole leaning body.

From our visual observation, the whole figure is weak and unstable.

•What can you say about the composition of the drawing? What is the effect of this type of composition on the overall drawing?

The composition of the picture is triangle.The compositions of the body which are head, back and the leg with dress in several layers. It can express light in the upper part of the body and heavy in the lower part of the body. Also, the whole figure is supported by the right leg.

•Is rhythm important in this picture? If so, say more about it...

Yes, there is rhythm in the picture.It can be shown on the draperies. There is the steady movement on the drapery.Also, the drapery was depicted in the detailed way and in the same direction.The rthyme is crucial to create the falling movement. 
•Is the picture balanced? Explain...

The drawing is well balanced since there is space on the top right-handed and left-handed corner. The figure is in the middle of the picture and catches the attention of the audience. The audience will naturally focus on her movement.

•Is perspective used in the picture? If so, describe the way that the illusion of three-dimensional space has been created.

The three-dimensional space has been created. Shading is used to reflect the three-dimensional space. The dress in the picture is the example.The cross layer of the dress is reflected by the dark or light shading. Even though the face and neck of the figure cannot be seen clearly, the darker shading can reflect the three-dimensional space. 


•Is the picture harmonious? If so, in what way?

Besides sadness, the picture is harmonious since the hair and hand of the woman make use of soft line.Also, the artist use only one color tone.Also, the color is yellow which is the warm color.Even though the women is crying, it gives the feeling of peaceful crying.
•Are there any strong contrasts in the picture? Say more...

The  strong contrast in the picture is the light and the darkness.The light of the picture is from the reflected light. The hair  and the upper part of the dress , which is round with many layers. The lower part of the dress is heavily shaded and dark since it is covered by the upper part of the body.

3) INTERPRETATION AND EVALUATION
•What is the mood of the drawing? Justify your answer using information from your responses above

The mood of the drawing is sadness , with a feeling of hopeless and depressed. The negative feeling comes from figure's movement and the technique, shading. To be more important, the movement of the figure contributes a lot. The figure cover her face with her hands . It seems that she was crying.
Even though the main color in the picture is yellow which is the warm colour, the movement catch our attention and lead us to think pessimistic.

•What does the drawing express? Justify your answer using information from your responses above

The drawing expresses the sadness hopeless of the women.I found some research that this is one of the character from  The Descent from the Cross.There are number of people watching the crucifixion and some helpers would like to save Christ from the cross. However, it is a tough process. It reflects the hopeless and sadness of the Mary who love and care about Christ.

•In your opinion, why is this work interesting/moving/ clever/ imaginative/thought-provoking/......?  Choose the adjective(s) that best fit(s) the work, and then justify your conclusion in terms of specific features and qualities of the drawing.

The work is thought-provoking since it can find out more the feeling of the people watching the crucifixion. Moreover, I can imagine the hopeless feeling through the picture.Also, the cold colour and shading lead me to have a chiily and horrible feeling towards the crucifixion.